A committee of professors and students spent 5 months studying how AI changed learning on campus, and the findings read like a warning to every university on the planet.
⭕ Study groups are disappearing.
⭕ Office hours are emptying out.
⭕ Problem sets and take-home exams no longer prove anything, because AI can produce credible solutions to almost any written assignment in the undergraduate curriculum.
⭕ Students who lean on chatbots lose mastery and confidence, and some slip into what the report calls cognitive surrender, reaching for AI at the first hint of struggle.
The committee warns MIT professors against replacing undergraduate research assistants with AI agents just because they’re cheaper, because a university exists to grow people, not output.
I publish book reviews on business books, the interactions have almost dropped to zero as have people in those channels. I imagine it’s related.
I try not to have discussions about AI online that are too lengthy, because I know no one really convinces anyone else, but every time I see someone talk about how they use local open weight models and how that makes their AI use ethical I think of scenarios exactly like this. That AI got the information from somewhere and that book or forum post or think piece is not getting the buys/engagement/ad revenue because the AI basically stole it. People aren’t joining communities and adding to a public knowledge base. They are just quietly solving their issue alone without contributing to the ecosystem that helped fix the issue and the ecosystems that sprung up around those.
It feels like a loss of so much. A loss of interest in research, but also of community, of a desire to share. I remember being on forums and knowing that if user X responded it was going to be the most thorough, interesting read. I remember following specific users because even if their post wasn’t directly relevant to me at the moment, I wanted to learn all I could from them. Not to be an old man screaming at a cloud, but I think AI is stripping a lot away from the younger generation that they don’t even know to miss, and I think that’d be true even if AI always provided the most engaging, in depth, accurate responses you could find on the internet.
I feel every word you typed. 💔
All true.
This was happening before “AI” though. It’s just oil for the fire.
I feel for you. I’m sure for authors, publishers, and consumers that such books and reviews have lost all credibility if sloppers can generate fakes with ease. It’s difficult to know whats real and can be trusted versus what’s just wasting our time.
Without a doubt.
And people who don’t know any better will believe what AI says. I see it at work all the time. People producing pages and pages of slop.
People join calls, output AI notes that clearly show they weren’t paying attention at all.